Basics
Thriving Species and Food Web
Salmon
Indicator
Number of natural-origin coho salmon on spawning grounds
Vital Sign Indicator
Each Unit (number)
/

No targets are currently set for this indicator.

Neala Kendall
Contributing Partners
Last Updated
2/15/2023 9:56:53 AM
Map
Coho salmon management unit spawner abundance relative to their low/normal escapement abundance breakpoints in effect in recent North of Falcon/Pacific Salmon Commission management for each unit in Puget Sound. The map shows the five-year (2017-2021) geomean of spawner abundance as a percentage of the breakpoint [(5-year geomean/breakpoint) *100]. Thus, the map shows which management units are further away (smaller numbers) vs. closer (larger numbers) to their breakpoint.
Description

This indicator evaluates the abundance values and their trends of five Puget Sound coho salmon management units as measured by the number of natural-origin adult fish on the spawning grounds. Abundance estimates here do not include hatchery-origin fish or coho salmon taken in harvest or by predators like orcas. The indicator is intended to reflect the abundance of wild coho salmon in Puget Sound, which are not federally listed under the Endangered Species Act.


Vital Sign Indicator Chart

Annual percent change in coho salmon management unit spawner abundance from 2000 to 2021 for each Puget Sound management unit. The lines show the 25th to 75th credibility intervals (CIs). CIs represent a range of values the true annual percent change likely falls within. All CIs contain zero, suggesting no statistically significant change in spawner abundance from 2000 to 2021 for all management units.

Coho salmon are a cultural icon of the Pacific Northwest. Currently they are less abundant than they were in the early 1900s. Returning coho are an essential part of Puget Sound’s marine and freshwater ecosystems, are prized by fishermen, and are subject to Tribal treaty protections. Continued monitoring of coho salmon abundance is essential to ensuring sustainable harvests and ecological integrity.

Key Vital Sign Indicator Results
  • Spawner abundance estimates of five management units of Puget Sound coho salmon have not changed significantly since the reference year of 2000.
  • Abundance of the five Puget Sound coho management units relative to their low/normal escapement abundance breakpoint ranges from 69% to 172% (see the indicator map). Recent 5-year geomean abundance of three management units are between 90% and 98% of their breakpoints. These breakpoint values determine the allowable harvest in a given year and help to establish the framework for sustainable harvest.
Methods
Monitoring Program

Coho salmon spawner abundance data are collected annually by WDFW and tribal co-manager staff as part of baseline monitoring and data collection efforts.

Data Source

Washington co-manager agreed-to datasets, as provided by WDFW staff including WDFW Fish Program District Biologists

Biologists typically estimate annual spawner abundance by counting the number of redds (gravel nests) in a river each year. Redds are counted by walking the stream or from boats or aircraft. In many populations, some hatchery-origin salmon are present on the spawning grounds along with natural-origin salmon, complicating the estimates of natural-origin abundance. The proportions of spawners that were of natural versus hatchery origin are typically estimated based on the composition of carcasses of each origin. These proportions are applied to the total spawning population to estimate the number of natural-origin versus hatchery-origin spawners.

Coho salmon spawner abundance is reported here as the number of natural-origin fish estimated on the spawning grounds (spawning naturally). We report on five key Puget Sound natural-origin coho salmon management units, for which abundance targets have been defined and for which natural-origin escapement estimates are produced.

Our analysis of abundance change over time answers the question:

Has the spawner abundance of Puget Sound coho salmon management units changed since 2000?

The year 2000 was selected as the baseline reference period because it is close to when Puget Sound Chinook salmon and Hood Canal summer chum salmon were listed under the ESA (1999) and provides a substantial time series for analysis.

In this trend evaluation, we fit a multivariate autoregressive state space random walk with drift (MARSS-RWD) model to the log of management unit spawner abundance data for all management units from 2000 to 2021. The model structure was identical to that used by NOAA Fisheries’ Northwest Fisheries Science Center in its 5-year status review with a few exceptions (Northwest Fisheries Science Center, 2015). The slope of each management unit’s smoothed abundance values was converted to percent change per year. If data were not available during these periods for a given management unit, data from the first or most recent years with available data were used.

To assess each management unit’s spawner abundance levels, we generated a “percent of target” by comparing the recent 5-year geometric mean (“geomean”) from the MARSS-RWD model against the low-normal escapement abundance breakpoints in effect under Pacific Fishery Management Council/Pacific Salmon Commission fisheries management. These breakpoint values determine the allowable harvest in a given year (as measured in pre- and post-season assessments of “exploitation rates”), and they help to establish the framework for sustainable harvest. Puget Sound coho salmon are not managed for recovery like our other salmon Vital Sign indicator species, and the breakpoints were not formulated in the context of Endangered Species Act requirements (i.e., they are harvest levels that do not prevent rebuilding).

For more information about the methods used for this indicator, please see the Status and Trends Analysis of Salmon Abundance Data methods report.

Critical Definitions
  • Natural-origin fish: fish produced by parents spawning in natural environments (not in a hatchery)
  • Natural-origin adult fish on the spawning ground: fish produced by parents spawning in natural environments that themselves returned to spawn in a natural environment
  • Population spawner abundance: number of natural-origin coho salmon estimated on the spawning grounds in a population
  • Hatchery-origin fish: fish produced by parents spawned in a hatchery
  • Endangered Species Act (ESA): Puget Sound coho salmon are not listed under the ESA
  • MARSS-RWD: multivariate autoregressive state space random walk with drift model, which was the statistical model used in our analyses
Interpretation of Results

Natural-origin, naturally-spawning abundance of the five Puget Sound coho management units with available data relative to their low/normal escapement abundance breakpoints is variable (Table 1). Abundance of one management unit is above its breakpoint (recent 5-year geomean is 172% of its breakpoint), one is below (69%), and another three are near their breakpoints (90-98%). Spawner abundance values fluctuate from year to year, often with no clear linear trends.

Table 1. Geometric mean (geomean) of model-smoothed coho salmon spawner abundance (2017-2021) and low/normal escapement abundance breakpoints of five Puget Sound management units.

Population Name

2017-2021 Geomean

Low/normal escapement abundance breakpoint

Geomean % of Low Prod. Planning Target*

Skagit 24,505 25,000 98%
Snohomish 45,126 50,000 90%
Stillaguamish 17,164 10,000 172%
Hood Canal 12,954 14,350 90%
Strait of Juan de Fuca 7,632 11,000 69%
*(5-year geomean/abundance breakpoint)*100

 

Salmon abundance in Puget Sound has been influenced by a myriad of factors including habitat, harvest, hydropower, and hatcheries, especially since European colonization. Harvest of coho is managed to maintain management units and is allocated between tribal and non-tribal fisheries. Coho salmon are no doubt aided by habitat restoration targeting ESA-listed salmon and steelhead populations.

Datasets

No datasets uploaded.

Reporting Guidance
Reporting Instructions
Subcategories

No Subcategories for this Puget Sound Indicator.